Nov, 2010 Update: actual award winners:
- NL MVP: Joey Votto, named first on 31/32 ballots.
- NL Cy Young: Roy Halladay, unanimous.
- NL Rookie: Buster Posey, rather easily over Jayson Heyward
- NL Mgr: Bud Black
Candidates and Guesses on the award winners for the 4 major categories per league. I originally wrote this towards the end of the season, and now am updating it based on how the season finished out.
AL MVP: Josh Hamilton (Cano 2nd unless voters get all NY-starry eyed). Miguel Cabrera getting is putting up serious numbers but the all around play of Hamilton is hard to miss.
AL Cy Young: Felix Hernandez. Back in late august I had CC Sabathia winning this, but Felix’s statistics pitching for such a poor team are overwhelming. Mid summer, this was David Price‘s award to lose and, well, he’s lost it. Cliff Lee was putting in a pretty strong summer as well but has really struggled since getting to Texas. Guys like Clay Buchholz (who led the Majors in ERA for a bit) and Trevor Cahill looking so strong. Lots of good starter performances in the AL this year.
AL Rookie: Neftali Felix, who has been lights out for the Rangers as their closer. Guys like Austin Jackson and Brendan Boesch have tailed off. Daniel Bard really isn’t in a position as a setup guy to be the impact player the others are. Reaching the post season and putting up good numbers there didn’t hurt.
AL Mgr: I’m going with Minnesota’s Ron Gardenhire. He coaxed 94 wins out of a team with a ho-hum pitching staff, a team that lost its closer in the pre-season and which didn’t have its leading slugger for the 2nd half of the season. Ron Washington also gets some credit, having taken a team with very little payroll to the top of their division. Its a bit less impressive though since the Rangers were already projecting to be a pretty good team.
NL MVP: Joey Votto. Pujols may be an equal, but Votto will win the “hey lets give it to someone else” crowd. I guess Adrian Gonzalez will come in a distant third.
NL Cy Young: Roy Halladay, who has been consistently and quietly awesome so far this year. Again this was another’s to lose (Ubaldo Jimenez) and indeed he has lost it, performing so badly in the last month that I considering dropping him from my fantasy team. Wainwright is up there for consideration as well. Latos, Josh Johnson, and Hudson are also having great seasons.
NL Rookie: Buster Posey. Yes he only came up in june, but to immediately slot in as the catcher, calling games for a rotation of elite starters AND being your teams cleanup hitter is impressive. That they made the playoffs and eventually won the World Series with Posey at the helm is even more impressive. In August this award was absolutely going to Jayson Heyward, but he tailed off and wasn’t nearly as exciting towards the end of the season as in the beginning. Jamie Garcia is in third place; it is hard to argue with a potential Cy Young candidate. Mike Stanton, Gaby Sanchez and even Stephen Strasburg were up for consideration at various times. Mike Leake‘s accomplishments are pretty noteworthy (not a day in the minors and making the MLB rotation on a playoff-bound team). Just a great rookie class in the NL this year.
NL Manager: Bud Black, though some serious consideration goes to Dusty Baker for the job he’s done in Cincinnati. But (in a similar story to Texas) to take a team nearly dead last in payroll to the top of a division with big time talent is tough. Bobby Cox has also done a nice job turning around Atlanta.