Well, Adam Kilgore beat me to the punch on this post earlier today, but I’ll still post my sentiments.
Scott Olsen put in yet another forgettable performance last night (gamer/box), lasting only 5 outs while giving up NINE earned runs in an ugly outing. His era rose from 4.91 to 5.88, his whip rose from 1.43 to 1.53 and his ERA+ dropped from an already mediocre 84 to 70. He drops to 3-8 on the season and the team is 5-10 in his starts.
The problem with Olsen is that his “highs” are not balancing out the lows. In 15 starts he’s pitched into the 7th inning twice (including one gem against Atlanta where he gave up 2 hits in 7 1/3 inning) but he’s had “meltdown” games no less than five times. (“meltdown” being defined as a game where the pitcher gives up at least as many runs as innings pitched).
Olsen arrived to the team with a history and a less-than-stellar fitness routine (he was a half-a-pack a day smoker). We havn’t heard a single peep about any attitude or smoking issues this year and I was impressed that he accepted last year’s non-tender and subsequently signed on for less than what he would have earned in arbitration to start the season. I’m less impressed with the results for this team.
Thankfully for Olsen, he won’t earn an outright release in the next few weeks, probably just getting sent to the bullpen or just shelved as Yunesky Maya gets called up to naturally make the 9/7 start on a normal 4 days rest. But, with an expected crowded race for next year’s rotation, he’s quickly earning himself a non-tender after the season is over.