So, the entire principle behind NOT signing Adam Dunn during the summer was the 2 draft picks we would acquire (the signing team’s 1st pick and a supplimental) after he declines our arbitration offer.
Check out this link at mlbtraderumors.com. If this site is correct, and the analysis is accurate, then Dunn has fallen just below the threshold and is now a Type B Free Agent.
From a Nats standpoint, this is an unmitigated Disaster. Now not only is there more incentive for other teams to sign him,there’s even LESS incentive for him to take a deal from us. And, we’ll get merely a supplimental 1st pick.
Unless the entire 2010 season was just a charade and we plan on signing him anyway. Per Boswell there’s a 3-year deal on the table now. But if you’re Dunn, you HAVE to see what is out there right now, right?
Assuming that he does not consider AL teams, as he has stated he wants to continue to play the field, here’s a quick rundown on NL teams and their 1st basemen situation:
NY: Ike Davis; up and coming prospect
PHI: Ryan Howard: long term contract
Fla: Gaby Sanchez (doesn’t matter, they’re not FA buyers)
Atl: Derrick Lee, who is a FA. Troy Glaus also a FA but was awful this year. Could be a buyer.
mil: Prince Fielder
Cincy: Joey Votto
Chi; it was Derrick Lee til they traded him. Possible FA buyers.
Hou; it was Lance Berkman til they traded him. But are they FA buyers? I don’t think so.
Pitt: Garrett Jones (doesn’t matter, they’re not FA buyers)
LA: James Loney: cost contained and home grown. plus no FA $$ spent until ownership divorce settled.
SD: Adrian Gonzalez
SF; Aubrey Huff: a FA and SF desperately needs hitters.
Col: Todd Helton; not the greatest hitter anymore but signed through 2013.
Ariz: Adam LaRoche who is a FA but I sense Ariz is rebuilding and not FA buyers
So, if he goes anywhere I think it could be either Atlanta, Chicago or San Francisco. Chicago already has some serious payroll issues and an underperforming team. SF may not have the payroll flexibility to buy Dunn despite really needing him. Atlanta only has $60M committed next year and has a bunch of arbitration cases … but they’ve spent over $100m on payroll as recently as 2 years ago and may expand it out again.
Adding in AL teams, looking at 1B solutions (I can’t see him signing up for a team that will ONLY DH him, so we have to look at teams where he splits time between 1B and DH).
Bos: Youklis/Victor Martinez
Tampa: Carlos Pena, a FA who will be allowed to walk. However, Tampa won’t buy Dunn
Tor: Lyle Overbay, a FA who is 34. Can’t see Toronto buying an aging FA w/ new GM in town.
Balt: Ty Wiggington: another aging mediocre FA. But are Orioles buyers?
CWS: Paul Konerko, a FA coming off a fantastic season; i see him resigning here.
Minn: Justin Morneau
KC: Billy Butler
Cle: Matt LaPorta, the future of this team right now and bounty from the CC Sabathia trade.
LAA: Kendrys Morales;
Oak; Daric Barton: up and coming hitter, only 24.
Sea: Russell Branyon/Casey Kotchman but they have Justin Smoak coming up (bounty for Cliff Lee).
Texas: Jorge Cantu/Chris Davis; rotating door post Smoak trade, but Mitch Moreland is prospect of the future.
So, from what I can tell there’s only really 4 AL teams that even have FA spots at 1B. Chicago (resigning Konerko), Tampa (not FA players), Toronto (are they FA buyers?) and Baltimore (why would Dunn go to a WORSE team than Washington?)
I still see him focusing on the NL. Based on this … Dunn seems like he may have options in the NL, which means our chances of having him accept a 3 year deal with us less likely. Not good news for us in 2011.