The Nats seemingly solved their catching issues for the next few years with the shrewd acquisition of Cleveland 2018 all-star catcher Yan Gomes. And they didn’t have to break the bank to do it.
They part ways with Jefry Rodriguez, who was probably sat #6 on the current Nats roster of starting pitchers, soon to be pushed further downwards with whatever acquisitions may yet to come, and who had proven over the course of the last two seasons he couldn’t be trusted with the ball for a playoff team. They also part ways with 2017 minor league POTY Daniel Johnson, cashing in on a guy who is still low minors but could flourish for a team like Cleveland. There’s also a PTBNL thrown in, usually indicative of a lower level prospect that Cleveland gets to pick from later on after scouting the Nats low-A team or something.
Johnson becomes the 4th player flipped from the 2016 draft, which is more and more looking like the best Nats draft in a decade. He joins Jesus Luzardo, Dane Dunning, and Sheldon Neuse heading out the door from that draft, and all three of these previously traded players have more or less flourished with their new organizations. Luzardo is now considered one of the best left-handed prospects in the game, Dunning regularly is called an “under the radar” type pitching prospect who the White Sox seem to be depending on as a solid mid-rotation piece in the future, and Neuse played all of 2018 in AAA as a 23-yr old after a 3-level rise in 2017.
(Yes, I’d like to have all of them back, especially Luzardo, who the team spent so much to acquire, nursed back to health and really could help with the current rotation crunch).
Nonetheless, for me this acquisition kicks off a series of new consequences for the 2019 team:
- No more pursuit of additional catchers, which should be a sigh of relief for Victor Robles fans, who had repeatedly been dangled to the Marlins for J.T. Realmuto. No longer.
- I like this Gomes acquistion, and I like the semi-platoon they now have setup with Kurt Suzuki. If one goes down with injury, the other can cover while they bring back up Kieboom for protection. This is such a better situation than we had the past two seasons, where had a crummy hitting, poor defending catcher in Matt Wieters with the likes of Kieboom or Severino as the guy getting regular day-after-night game starts.
- Pedro Severino‘s days are numbered; no options, no roster spot for 2019. He’ll hang around all spring to guard against injury, but faces a looming DFA next April 1st. Will he get picked up by another team? Perhaps. He was just so bad at the plate in 2018 that its hard to project any team giving him even a backup role, no matter how good his defense is.
- If Severino stays in the system though, he’ll likely push downwards in a cascading manner our current catching “depth,” since he’ll join Spencer Kieboom in AAA, That pushes Taylor Gushue back to AA, likely with Raudy Read who seems lost in the shuffle here. That then leaves Jakson Reetz and Tres Barrera basically repeating High-A for the time being. I don’t think any of these guys are really pushing for promotion necessarily based on offensive performance: Gushue hit .212 in AA in 2018, Read hit much better in AA but showed almost no power in a half-season in AAA, Reetz has never hit even .240 in any stop since the rookie league, and Barrera hit good but not amazing in Potomac. Probably the best case would be to just part ways with Severino, and have this be your C depth in 2019:
- AAA: Read and Kieboom splitting time evenly
- AA: Gushue and Barrera, who probably needs a promotion
- High-A: Reetz and perhaps one of the low-A 2018 catches like Alejandro Flores or Alex Dunlop
Suffice it to say … we have very little reliable catching depth in our minors right now. Thankfully Gomes has options through 2021 for reasonable money.
- We already knew we had no SP depth, and now we just traded our primary backup hurler. Not that i’m enamored of Jefry Rodriguez and think he’s our savior … but I do slightly question the choice of player to ship out. I understand “trading from strength” and I also understand that you have to give up something to get something … but this team has traded away SO MUCH starting pitching over the past few years that I wonder if they need to, you know, save some of it? As has been noted elsewhere, the last time the Nats developed and kept a for-real MLB starter was Stephen Strasburg, which, lets be honest, even the most incompetent organization could have done. Here’s a list of the starters we’ve traded away in the last 2 years: Jefry Rodriguez, McKenzie Mills, Tyler Watson, Jesus Luzardo, Taylor Hearn, Pedro Avila, Lucas Giolito, Reynaldo Lopez, Dane Dunning. That’s a ton of starters. And now we’re looking at acquiring even more via trade or FA. At some point we have to stop spending money on FA starters and grow them from within.
- This was actually a fantastic Salary Cap move: Gomes counts just $3.8M towards the 2019 luxury tax cap. With all the tenders and salary estimates, I still have the team $43M under the cap, so that’s plenty of room to buy the upgrades they need.
In the end…. one major position of need down (C), two more to go (SP and 2B).