It isn’t every day that you see a guy like Trevor Bauer traded. Why?
- He was traded less than a year after being drafted in the upper 1st round (3rd overall).
- He was traded despite signing a Major League deal and getting a $3.4M bonus. The bonus money isn’t exactly a sunk cost here; we’re not talking about a guy who is 5 years into his minor league career.
- He was traded despite being the first player from his draft class to matriculate to the majors, appearing at the end of 2012’s season, getting 4 starts in September.
- He was traded after a minor league season in which (among AA and AAA) he compiled a 12-2 record with a 2.42 ERA with 157 K’s in 130 1/3 innings, including time spent in the hitter-bonanza PCL. As a 21-year old.
- He was traded after being named Arizona’s Minor League Pitcher of the Year.
- He was traded despite in-arguably being considered an “Ace” pitching prospect.
So, why was Arizona so quick to give up on this guy? It isn’t like they moved Bauer to get a game-changing set of prospects or impact major league players; the return seems to be a lighter-hitting shortstop (Didi Gregorius), an inconsistent reliever (Tony Sipp) and a first base prospect who is immediately blocked on the Arizona roster by other, better players (Lars Anderson).
The answer seems to be a combination of several factors, none of them flattering to Bauer and his make-up/personality:
- Bauer’s refusal to alter his unique warm-up methods. We saw this coming; he issued a “warning” to drafting teams that he did not want his extreme long-toss warmup method changed or questioned.
- Bauer’s refusal to allow his catcher to call the game. In his four September games, he repeatedly shook off catcher Miguel Montero, a seven year veteran catcher. And that didn’t seem to go over well with either catcher or coach when asked about it at the time.
- Bauer’s approach during his MLB time; he reportedly pitches “backwards,” setting up hitters with off-speed stuff before using his fastball as his outpitch. But this approach is counter to most recommended approaches for attacking hitters, especially bottom-of-the-order hitters. He reportedly nibbled too much, didn’t go after hitters, walked a number of 7-8-9 guys, and then (in a common refrain) refused to alter his approach.
- Bauer’s tantrum when removed from the PCL championship game, showing up AAA manager Billy Butler (an accomplished MLB veteran) in the process.
- Bauer’s maturity level being questioned in the media by the team’s owner.
- Bauer’s clubhouse demeaner reportedly being, shall we say, “less than optimal” for getting along well with others. I can’t find links off-hand, but I read opinions that describe Bauer variously as being “an Ass,” being cocky, being “prickly,” being a know-it-all, and already dividing the MLB clubhouse despite his relative short time there.
Ok, that’s a long list of issues, some of them very serious when it comes to a professional ball-player.
Its easy to say, “well the kid is only 21” and excusing any/all these issues. But there is something to be said about a 21 year old kid arriving in a Major League ball club, with a manager of the pedigree and career accomplishments of Kirk Gibson and an on-the-field staff of old-school pros (including Don Baylor, Matt Williams and pitching coach Charles Nagy), and telling them that he knows better than they do. Perhaps its that simple; perhaps the management had already essentially given up on Bauer’s ability to be coached, to receive instruction, to even receive recommondations, and GM Josh Towers pulled the plug.
But he’d have to be just incredibly hard headed for the team to have already arrived at the point of no return. We’re not talking about some random 15th rounder. We’re talking about a game-changing, significant investment they made in this kid.
Bauer, for his part, clearly has confidence in his approach, studied and crafted his motion based on biomechanical information he had at hand (his major at UCLA? Biomedical Engineering), and believes that his preparation and his motion are what has enabled him to garner a high 1st round pick, what allowed him to zoom through the minors, and are what will enable him to be a successful professional. I can understand his viewpoint; why should I change what has gotten me where I am now? In some ways this reminds me of the whole “old-school/new-school” arguments that we have related to evaluating baseball players; new-school sabrematricians clearly have a dim view of their old-school/veteran sports writer counter parts and often have no issue writing that such-and-such a veteran sportswriter is flat out “an idiot.” Well; is Bauer the “new school” approach to crafting pitching mechanics and his Arizona coaches are the “old school” approach to teaching pitching?
In some ways, we as fans forget that a clubhouse is rather similar to an office environment; you have “good” and “bad” workers, you have super stars and people just playing out the string. Imagine if you had a 21-yr old hot-shot rookie just out of school who came in and told you (a seasoned veteran of some accomplish) that he knew how to do his job better than you? I would imagine that the kid would seem pretty grating in the process. Is this what happened in Arizona?
Should we be putting any blame on the Organization? This isn’t the first time we’ve heard “issues” revolving around Arizona, their staff and management, and a player. In addition to the Bauer situation, the continual Justin Upton trade rumors, persisting on now for a second off-season. If the guy (Upton) is so good, why has the team been trying to move him for 2 years? They benched him in 2012 and he got into a public spat with the owner this past season. Is this a player issue or is there something in the organization that keeps rearing its head? The situation reminds me somewhat of the Aaron Crow draft situation, where Jim Bowden drafted a kid who apparently had made it known he wanted no part of the organization. If Arizona knew going in that Bauer was going to be difficult, why draft him at all?