First draft of this post: May 8th, 2014, just 5 weeks into the season, with the announcements of MLB players of the month and early MVP watch columns from national baseball writers .
- NL MVP: Kershaw over Stanton, McCutchen and Lucroy
- NL Cy Young: Kershaw over Cueto and Wainwright
- NL Rookie: deGrom over Hamilton
- NL Manager: Bochy over Roenicke
- AL MVP: Trout over Victor Martinez, Cano, Abreu and Cruz.
- AL Cy Young: Felix, barely over Kluber, Sale, others.
- AL Rookie: Abreu over Tanaka, Shoemaker, Ventura, and others.
- AL Manager: Showalter over McLendon, Yost.
So, how did the major awards evolve this year? Read below for a running diary of the front runners for each major award. It makes for a fascinating read of the season. By my sense, the awards kind of went like this from April to September:
- NL MVP: Tulowitzki early, then Stanton, maybe McCutchen, then Kershaw, back to Stanton and finally Kershaw with Stanton’s injury.
- NL Cy Young: Cueto at the start, Jose Fernandez til he got hurt, then Bumgarner, Wainwright, then clearly Kershaw.
- NL Rookie: Chris Owings, then Wong, then Hamilton, maybe Polanco, suddenly deGrom.
- AL MVP: Abreu then Bautista, Encarnacion, Cruz, then Trout, no doubt. Everyone else racing for #2.
- AL Cy Young: Sonny Grey, then Scherzer, then Buehrle, then Felix, maybe Kluber, down to wire.
- AL Rookie: Abreu, then Tanaka, Ventura, then clearly Abreu with Tanaka’s injury.
Ahead of this post, some non MLB-affiliated awards have been given out.
- Matt Williams was named The Sporting News’ NL Manager of the Year, which readers here probably laugh at considering the mess he made of his pitching decisions in the NLDS.
- Craig Kimbrel and Greg Holland won the NL and AL reliever of the year awards, named after Trevor Hoffman and Mariano Rivera respectively.
- The Gold Gloves were announced yesterday: you’d have to be crazy to try to predict those
This year, instead of printing links to writers early and mid-season predictions, I’ll just throw those links into the monthly reviews for context. This post is more like a season-long diary of the evolution of these awards; the sections were written in each month as the season progressed.
Players-of-the-month in April do not very frequently win MVPs, Cy Youngs or Rookie of the Year awards, but we may see a surprise in 2014 thanks to some big-time performances. But here’s where we stand after the first month.
Opinions this month: Corcoran on early candidates.
- MVP candidates: Troy Tulowitzki, Giancarlo Stanton in the NL. Colorado’s Charlie Blackmon deserves mention for his amazing April. Jose Abreu and Jose Bautista in the AL (with apologies to perennial contenders Miguel Cabrera and Mike Trout, both of whom started slow).
- Cy Young candidates: Johnny Cueto and Jose Fernandez in the NL. Sonny Grey and Max Scherzer in the AL.
- Rookie of the year candidates: Chris Owings in the NL, Jose Abreu in the AL. Masahiro Tanaka could make some noise in the AL though for sure.
- MVP candidates: Still Tulowitzki in the NL (he has a full 1.0 WAR lead midway through the month and had accumulated 4 WAR just six weeks into the season! Even more impressive; he’s hitting ABOVE .500 at home thus far), but Stanton has also been on fire (as my fantasy team can attest). Yasiel Puig may be a lightening rod, but he’s also one of the best players in the NL and has put his name into the NL MVP conversation by winning player of the month.. Jody Donaldson has been on fire in the AL and is getting some notice, but also so has Nelson Cruz, who may be the best FA signing of the off-season. Abreu went on the D/L. Bautista remains the best offensive WAR player in the AL. But by months’ end Trout was near the top of the WAR list despite a “slump.” Edwin Encarnacion cannot stop hitting and is leading Toronto to a big lead in the AL East, and won player of the month in the AL for May, but i’m doubtful he’ll eventually figure in the MVP race.
- Cy Young candidates: Cueto still leads in the NL when early front-runner Fernandez goes down to TJ Surgery, despite the Nats tagging him for 8 runs in a mid-May game. Adam Wainwright is quietly having an excellent season, as is Zack Greinke. Jeff Samardzija might be the best pitcher of them all but still has zero wins thanks to the vagarities of the Win statistic (that and his team’s purposelly awful offense). Madison Bumgarner won May pitcher of the month, but doesn’t seem like he’s nearly as dominant as the other pitchers mentioned here. Lastly we need to mention Tim Hudson‘s great start. Scherzer and Tanaka still involved in the AL race, but Mark Buehrle‘s turn-back-the-clock season is gaining notice and Houston’s Dallas Keuchel is having an amazing season for the 110 loss Astros. Meanwhile Felix Hernandez is quietly dominant, posting an 8-1 record out in Seattle. And Yu Darvish is basically unhittable (as the Nats learned in late May).
- Rookie of the year candidates: Owings remains in the lead in the NL among little competition pending expected mid-season callups (Corcoran’s May #2 is Atlanta’s David Hale, who was demoted to the bullpen after 4 starts when Gavin Floyd was ready to go), but Kolten Wong‘s showing has his name in the discussion (he was May’s MLB rookie of the month). Abreu hit the D/L (and his numbers may be impressive from a power stand point but little else), while Tanaka continues his dominance and takes over the AL lead. Meanwhile the amazing arm of Yordano Ventura pokes his head into this race … and then he got hit with injury. But the new leader in the AL RoY clubhouse may very well be Houston’s George Springer, who hit seven homers in 7 games in late May and is on pace for 40 as a rookie.
Opinions: Lindholm’s early Rookie of the Year look. Lindholm’s Cy Young Predictions (except that he focuses entirely on advanced pitching stats that, lets face it, the voter-base doesn’t care about). Corcoran take on the Rookies. Corcoran update on MVP race. Passan’s half-year awards column. Brisbee mid-season AL Awards and mid-season NL-Awards (which he thinks are stupid :-). MLB June Rookies of the month announcement.
- MVP candidates: Still Tulowitzki in the lead in the NL, though Stanton probably finishes in the top 3 thanks to his first ever healthy season enabling him to chase 50 homers. Puig has cooled a bit. Jonathan Lucroy has thrown his name into top-5 consideration thanks to his great offensive season tacked on top of his great defensive prownesses. And last years’ MVP Andrew McCutchen has thrown his name into the ring with a great June and the MLB player of the month award. In the AL, Trout’s consistency has giving him the lead over AL east bashers Bautista and Cruz (and he won MLB’s MVP for June). Tanaka will probably get top 5 votes but won’t win; see the Cy Young section for a statement on his “rookie” season. One can only hope that a down year (thus far) for Cabrera will finally eliminate the narrative-driven voting for him over Trout that has occurred the last two years; Trout’s numbers right now eclipse his numbers in his first two years. Meanwhile you have to start giving Jose Altuve some props: at the half-way point of the season he’s leading the AL in Batting Average, Hits and Stolen Bases, each by a considerable margin. I’d have him in my top5.
- Cy Young candidates: Wainwright has overtaken Cueto for the NL lead right now, but if Kershaw keeps throwing scoreless innings (he’s on a streak of 28 as of the time of this writing), he’ll move into the lead (MLB just gave Kershaw pitcher of the month for June). Julio Teheran probably earns a top-5 spot thanks to his breakout season. And one Jake Arrieta has added his name to the mix thanks to his pretty amazing turnaround in Chicago. In the AL, Tanaka still leads King Felix, with Texas-based hurlers Darvish and Keuchel knocking on the door but slightly cooling. But Felix was named AL’s June pitcher of the month and would be a no-brainer if he didn’t have the West Coast anti-bias working against him.
- Rookie of the year candidates: In the NL, no candidates are really distinguishing themselves. Right now Owings remains in the WAR lead over Billy Hamilton (who was named Rookie of the Month for June and is in the lead right now) but neither player is that inspiring. However the eventual favorite may have finally gotten his callup in Gregory Polanco. Meanwhile the AL race almost certainly is looking like a 1-2 International FA contest between Tanaka and Abreu, with Tanaka easily winning right now (though Abreu won June’s Rookie of the Month award). There’s almost no reason to mention anyone else, which is unfair to Houston’s budding stars George Springer and Jon Singleton.
- Comeback Player of the Year: This award always flies under the radar, but we have a couple of decent candidates getting some mention. In the NL, Casey McGehee was run out of the MLB thanks to injuries and awful hitting in 2012; after a dominant year in Japan he’s having a nice bounce-back for Miami. And, after just 8 awful starts in 2013, LA’s Josh Beckett is looking pretty dominant so far this year. Tim Hudson‘s come-back year after his gruesome ankle injury earns some mentions. The AL version is harder to find candidates: Passan mentions Joakim Soria and Phil Hughes as early candidates. I like Hughes; 4-14 with a 5+ ERA last year who is having success this year.
- Managers of the Year: at the halfway point, we can start to see some clarity in the Manager of the Year (also known as the “guy in charge of the team that has the most shocking W/L record award.” Right now we’re we’re looking at Bob Melvin, manager of Oakland and their best-in-the-majors 81-game record in the AL and (easily right now) Ron Roenicke, who is leading the surprising Milwaukee Brewers to the best record in the NL at the halfway point.
- MVP candidates: In the NL, Colorado’s waning playoff chances are knocking down Tulowitzki’s chances, while Stanton continues to produce staggering offensive numbers. Meanwhile McCutchen is coming on strong and may lead Pittsburgh on a 2nd half run. In the AL, the Angels success finally ends the 3-year running narrative based arguments that have prevented Trout from winning an MVP. At this point, if he doesn’t win, its because some bloc of writers has conspired against him. Batista and Cruz continue to be 2-3 on my ballot. At the end of the month, Trout leads the majors in bWAR with Tulowitzki not far behind.
- Cy Young candidates: In the NL, it is looking like Wainwright versus Kershaw. Wainwright in the lead now, but Kershaw’s dominance may carry him to the title by the end of the year. In the AL; Felix Hernandez has overtaken Tanaka, who hit the D/L with a partially torn UCL that may force him into Tommy John. Chris Sale has put his name into contention as the #3 candidate right now. Kershaw/Fernandez are 1/2 in bWAR at the end of the month.
- Rookie of the year candidates: In the NL, Hamilton still holds off Polanco, but the Pittsburgh rookie has been great since his call up. Check back on this race later. In the AL, Tanaka’s D/L trip also may cost him his unanimous Rookie of the Year award, which now goes to the 1-A candidate Abreu. No one else is close; If I had to guess who was #3 in this race, i’d go Springer.
- Comeback Player of the Year: Still looking like Hudson and Hughes for now.
- Managers of the Year: Still Roenicke and Melvin for now. There’s no other obvious candidates.
Opinions: Calcaterra on who is MVP. A list of most improved players by WAR in mid-August. (which should be a good way to talk about Comeback players, except that it really is just highlighting former role players who are having great years). Paul Swydan talked about the NL MVP vote in mid-August. Keith Law’s mid-august preview of the awards. Crasnick’s 8/25/14 chat talking about AL Manager of the Year candidates. Bowden’s rookie Rankings from late august. HardballTalkDaily video says the Rookie races are pretty clear cut on 8/29/14.
- MVP candidates: Jayson Werth was named July NL player of the month, but seems like a long shot to get anything other than 5th place MVP votes. Meanwhile previous leaders Tulowitzki AND now McCutchen are both on the D/L and missing at least a month each, so questions abound. Is Puig the front runner now? Stanton? A pitcher? At this point it may end up being Kershaw thanks to some deficiencies in the cases of both these healthy candidates, except that Kershaw missed quite a few starts and many voters won’t even give him the Cy Young nod as a result. And there’s the small fact that apparently sportswriters are starting to place Barry Bonds-level hatred on Puig (I heard a 3rd-party story that does not flatter Puig in the least in terms of his attitude and self-opinion, so this does not shock me). Abreu earned his second AL Player of the Month but seems like a long shot to beat out Trout at this point; the Angels seem set to make the playoffs, removing the “narrative” that has prevented Trout from being the MVP in years past. In fact, the 2nd best candidate in the AL may very well be Felix Hernandez, who won’t win on some ballots because he’s a pitcher. Alex Gordon is starting to get some MVP notice, thanks to his leadership on the suddenly-playoff-bound Royals. I see him as a good top-5 candidate.
- Cy Young candidates: In the NL, Kershaw has earned his second NL pitcher of the month award and (despite missing several starts) seems like a lock to win another Cy Young award. Meanwhile in the AL, Grey has earned another pitcher of the month award, but Hernandez and Sale seem to be 1-2 in this race as long as Tanaka stays on the shelf. Corey Kluber has put together a great season, but he’s chasing Hernandez for 2nd place right now.
- Rookie of the year candidates: In the NL, Mets starter Jacob deGrom has put his name into the hat thanks to a slew of dominant starts, and was just named July rookie of the month. In a weak field, he could push to a victory. But no sooner did he win the monthly award than go down to injury, likely cementing the award for Hamilton. In the AL, not only was Abreu named rookie of the month, he was also named player of the month. The longer Tanaka stays on the D/L, the more Abreu solidifies his hold on this award. Brandon Shoemaker quietly has a 13-4 season for the Angels but may not even broach the top 5 in voting, thanks to the huge glut of quality AL rookies this year.
- Comeback Player of the Year: Still looking like Hudson and Hughes for now.
- Managers of the Year: In the AL, surprising runs by the Mariners, Orioles and Royals have their three managers (respectively, Lloyd McClendon, Buck Showalter and Ned Yost) will get some attention. In the NL, I still think Milwaukee’s turn-around keeps Ron Roenicke in the lead.
You know its starting to get close to silly season; lots of opinion pieces start popping up right after labor day.: Brisbee’s “handicapping” of the NL awards on 9/1/14 and the same for the AL awards two days later. Schoenfield’s Heyward for MVP article 9/2/14. NL awards video from Schoenfield 9/2/14. USAtoday’s early Sept Awards preview. Jim Bowden pops up for Executive of the Year predictions. Schoenfield extolling McCutchen’s credentials in mid September. Cory DiBenedetto at GammonsDaily talking about the AL RoY and then the NL RoY. Passan’s late Sept award column. Jayson Stark’s final prediction column. Anthony Castrovince’s prediction column. Schoenfield’s “best rookies” column.
- MVP candidates: In the NL, it was looking more and more like Stanton’s continued massive offensive season was driving the narrative towards his getting the MVP. However, an awful-looking HBP likely ended Stanton’s season on 9/11/14 … will those lost two weeks prevent him from taking the top spot now? It seems so; I’m predicting Kershaw wins both MVP and Cy Young. A pitcher hasn’t gotten the NL Cy Young in more than 40 years. The NL WAR leader-board shows the problem with using WAR as a projection tool of MVP (as Brisbee’s column points out: there’s just no way that NL positional player bWAR leader Jason Heyward is getting the MVP no matter how much you believe in defensive stats. Buster Posey‘s huge summer has put his name into the hat for top-5 candidates. Speaking of top-5 candidates, do you put Anthony Rendon into that discussion? In the AL, there’s just no way Trout doesn’t get the award this year, so we’ll discuss runners-up later on. Brisbee seems to think Robinson Cano will somehow sneak into the discussion but I don’t think so. Victor Martinez‘s excellent/no-frills offensive season should have him getting some top-5 love. Michael Brantley looks to earn some top 5 votes too.
- Cy Young candidates: In the NL, Kershaw has solidified his hold on the award. The better question may be whether he also wins the MVP. In the AL I think its safe to say Hernandez-Kluber go 1-2, though a September swoon may cost Felix votes. It could get really close. Expecially after Felix got pounded on 9/23/14 in his 2nd to last start.
- Rookie of the year candidates: In a weak NL field, DeGrom’s fantastic 2nd half seems to be pushing him over the top of the obvious candidate for most of the year in Hamilton. Kyle Hendricks may get top 5 votes. In the AL, it has to be Abreu, likely unanimously unless a couple of NYC writers do the homer-vote for Tanaka.
- Comeback Player of the Year: Still looking like Hudson and Hughes, but this award is unpredictable. Passan’s late Sept column points out a couple of NL candidates to consider, since Hudson’s ERA cratered in the 2nd half. Casey McGhee returned from Japanese exile to have a great season, and Justin Morneau has come back from the DFA heap to nearly lead the NL in batting. In the AL one should also consider former Nats AAA pitcher Chris Young, who has absolutely come back from nowhere to stay healthy an entire year. He should write the Nats a thank-you card for giving him a paycheck to rehab on our dime.
- Managers of the Year: I can’t see the writers giving Manager of the year awards to a team like Washington (which was expected to win) nor the Angels (which has a monster payroll and the best player in the game). It may be someone like Bruce Bochy in the NL, who has overcome the loss of his two marquee pitchers and a slew of curious signings to keep the Giants in playoff contention. In the AL, perhaps Showalter deserves some mention for what he’s done in Baltimore … but then again, have we ever seen an AL east meltdown top to bottom like we’re seeing this year? More and more i’m liking what Showalter is doing with Baltimore and a relatively unknown pitching staff and a ton of injuries.